| Platinum | Tires Plus |
| Gold | Discount Tire |
| Silver | 5 Seasons Tire |
| Bronze | Mt. Vernon Road Tire |
| Top Pick | Al's Full Service Auto Repair |
| Top Pick | Blairs Ferry Tire & Auto Service In |
| Top Pick | Collins Road Tire Company |
| Top Pick | Five Seasons Tire |
| Top Pick | Marion Tire |
| Top Pick | Pomp's Tire |