| Platinum | Main Street Bakery and Cafe |
| Gold | French Pastry by Sandrine |
| Silver | That One Cupcake Place |
| Bronze | Shelly's Sweets |
| Top Pick | County Line Acres LLC |
| Top Pick | Feedwell Kitchen & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Great Harvest Bread Company |
| Top Pick | Kathy's Pies |
| Top Pick | Shawnniecakes |
| Top Pick | Sweet Cheesecake |