| Platinum | Lacayo |
| Gold | Villa's Patio Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | Eva's Mexican |
| Bronze | El Bajio Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Caucho |
| Top Pick | El Paraiso Mexican Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Jambayz Island Grill |
| Top Pick | Mamacitas |
| Top Pick | Rio Burritos |
| Top Pick | Taco Depot |
| Carlos O'Kelly's Mexican Cafe |