| Platinum | Napoli's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Need Pizza |
| Gold | Zio Johno's |
| Silver | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano |
| Top Pick | Gianna's Italian Beef |
| Top Pick | Popoli |
| Top Pick | Via Sofia's |
| Top Pick | Vino's Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Vito's On 42nd |