| Platinum | Eternal Bling Permanent Jewelry |
| Gold | Tangled Heartstrings |
| Silver | Siebke Hoyt Jewelers |
| Bronze | Boyson Jewelry |
| Top Pick | Frenchique |
| Top Pick | Ginsberg Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Helzberg |
| Top Pick | Philip's Diamond Shop |
| Top Pick | Rejewel Custom Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Siegel's Jewelry & Loan |